I grew up with James Caan, in a manner of speaking; that is to say, I grew up with him the way we all did…while watching his films.
I don’t know much about his life other than he was born and reared in the Bronx and that he has a reputation of being a tough guy.
…And if my mother was alive, she’d be his age now, which is 80.
James Caan is one of many Hollywood tough guys–on screen and off. A tender heart and a threadbare vulnerability differentiated him and his characters, making it almost impossible to root against them and–existentially–him. And that made him a blue-collar superstar in the late 60’s to the early 80’s and fueled his resurgence in the 90’s.
James Caan is sexy. Women like him. Men like him.
In Michael Mann’s 1981 debut feature film, Thief (1981), Caan’s “Frank” is a career criminal on top of his game. The only footsteps he hears behind him are from Father Time.
Frank, takes down big scores. He deals only in cash and diamonds that he procures with a skeleton crew of trusted professionals in elaborate, carefully orchestrated heists. He isn’t greedy. And he stays clear of the mob.
Frank lives very comfortably. And he lives alone.
He is nearing his forties. He wants a family and a normal life.
To that end he becomes acquainted with a pretty cashier/hostess in the cafe where he takes his meals. There is an attraction, a familiarity, though they do not know each other. Her name is Jessie (Tuesday Weld) and Frank pursues her immediately, with blatant determination so honest, so desperate that she agrees to be his soulmate on a whim.

Jessie too, has a criminal past that she has been keeping at a respectable distance. Frank assures her that he is one big heist away from being able to retire in style.
And style is very important to Frank. It is the one thing that slows the dogged pursuit of his own self doubt.
Jessie tells him she can’t have children. Frank shrugs it off. “We’ll adopt,” he says.
Michael Mann takes these familiar troupes of noir and runs with them in Thief, starting with his own screenplay that borrows from the memoir of jewel thief, John Allen Seybold’s Home Invaders: Confessions of a Cat Burglar. Seybold served as a consultant to the film while he was being hunted by the FBI.
It is fun to watch Mann’s directorial signatures taking shape before anyone knew who he was. Signatures like wet streets with neon colors reflecting off them, elegant camera work capturing the frailty of life through the lens of grindhouse spectacle and intricate attention to the art of the heist and sporadic violence, all of it set to a pulsing, synthesized soundtrack.
Yet, for all that (and one of the greatest heist sequences in movie history in which the industrial arts inform the cinematic) Thief is essentially a tragic character study, wrapped in the trappings of a neo-noir. It is the story of a man who has spent his entire life on the outside looking in, a man who takes great pride in his work but can barely speak of it.
It is a story of a thief with principals shaped in foster homes and prison cells who will set his dreams ablaze for the sake of them–and for revenge.
This is an undoubtedly stylish film, but I didn’t get that involved in it. Unlike many film fans, I find James Caan unappealing to watch. I thought he was badly miscast as Sonny in ‘The Godfather’, and his later performances had me more interested in his strange hairpieces, than his characters.
He suited the part in ‘Misery’, and I have just bought a cheap DVD of ‘Flesh and Bone’, so will see later how he does in that film.
Best wishes, Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hmm…Obviously, I can’t disagree with you more. Ha! Nonetheless, I respect your opinion. I doubt that you will be impressed with Flesh and Bone. While I appreciate it, largely because of the cast–particularly Paltrow and Caan–it falters in direction.
But, then again, that’s just my opinion.
Thanks for reading.
–Pam
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep, this is a good film by Michael Mann, although I don’t think it’s his best one: a great use of sound and silence, almost unreal scene of the environment, and still being realistic. Great actors, especially James Caan gives a strong performance.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, it’s a clinic in the use of sound and silence and to that I would add color. To me, it is the epitome of 80s cinematic style that went on to inform directors like Nichols Winding Refn and Edgar Wright and for those reasons I think it is his best film among a career of many good films.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the reminder, Pam! Maybe I gonna watch “Thief” again. I was also impressed by “Heat”. Very intense movie with many narrative threads.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I loved Heat, as well. The shootout sequence during the bank robbery is unprecedented in choreography and realism. The audio editing alone in the sequence is astounding. Yet, for all that, I prefer Thief and the burn bar sequence.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very stylish and less pretentious than some of Mann’s recent films. As you said, it is really a simple movie (character study disguised as a heist movie), stylishly done.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree. To me, it is a nearly perfect film that works in the nuance between style and sincerity.
Thanks for reading.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nice review, Pam. I watched James Caan on an old western television series. I think it was Gunsmoke. Anyway, he was mighty hot. I have always liked him. 80? eegads.
LikeLiked by 1 person
True that…true that.
LikeLike
I now have to watch this film again 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
And you will enjoy it. I’d bet money on it.
LikeLike
Great review 🙂 Along with James Caan’s performance (I love that dialogue in the restaurant scene), who could forget Tangerine Dream’s electronic score – in case you are not aware, I am a huge fan of the aforementioned group 🙂 Some diehard Michael Mann fans have suggested that it thematically serves as something of a dress rehearsal for his 1995 crime epic Heat. Interesting isn’t it? 🙂 Anyway, keep up the great work as always 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I would say that Thief is a precursor to Heat more than a dress rehearsal. I personally prefer Thief to Heat, but that’s just my opinion.
The restaurant scene and dialogue are terrific, no doubt.
Thanks for reading.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can almost get the vibe of your Lenny in that cafe image! (Still a few episodes behind hopefully this weekend) but I don’t think Lenny would have his leg up on the seat. Be so cocky?
Thief is a really good film. Especially in look.
I went back to see my notes on it in my “what’s been watched” I gave it 7.5/10 and just wrote “Safecracker gangster flick. Write up should come soon….” Bugger I forgot about it but you’ve made up for it Pam. Like the way you tackled it.
I love the soundtrack like JC above. “Not that one!!” LOL Actually I wonder if that JC likes a bit of Tangerine Dream as he dishes out the fishes and loaves? Of course I digress!
It’s weird! I’m not the biggest James Caan fan but the dude is in so many brilliant and fav films.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thief really struck an accord with me, Mikey. 7.5 is pretty dang good on the Wolfie meter. Yes, I love the Tangerine Dream soundtrack. Some critics really hated it in the day, or so I read. Probably some old farts who gripes about synthesized music. Same type of people who think EDM sucks as a medium…I agree, Thief is visually stunning. A beautiful film to look at.
Thanks for stopping by, Mikey. Always a pleasure.
–Pam
LikeLike
This was a terrific film and while Caan did have a bad boy rep off the screen,he was very good on it….from doing westerns with John Wayne to the moving “Brian’s Song”,I have always enjoyed his work. His death scene in The Godfather has to be among the most brutal in movie history. Its been a long time since I watched Thief so I would need to watch it again before offering any thoughts.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, we agree about James Caan, for sure. I guess I can see where he might rub some people wrong–he’s cocky, but he has a gentleness too. I’ve never really considered that there are film fans who don’t like Caan before, but now I know that there are. Ha! You learn something new everyday!
I think you would enjoy revisiting Thief. The safe-cracking sequence alone deserves a second look.
Thanks for reading, Micheal.
–Pam
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Pam…it brings back a lot of memories renting this way back in the day of VHS. I do like the ending also.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ha! Those were good days, renting VHS from
Blockbuster, or wherever. Simpler times. We held something tangible that helped us make our choice–the VHS box. Renting a VHS tape was an event of sorts and there was anticipation involved. It was fun.
Yes, the ending…it sticks with you.
–Pam
LikeLiked by 1 person
You know…I really miss doing that. I would look forward going to the momand pop one we had to see what they had. Not always blockbusters but really good movies like this one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My husband still to this day will randomly turn to me and say, “We own it.”
Big Caan fan. Love him so much. Did you see him in Elf? lol
Michael M. definitely loves thieves and/or “high-scale” robbers. Nice review! I think
we should see this again!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes. That safe “cracking” sequence was something else. But before they could crack the safe they had to defeat the massive security system. Once they did that…well, they owned it. But of course you already know that. Ha!
Yes, I saw him in Elf. Genius. He seems to have a great sense of humor. He’s a tough guy that can laugh at himself. Amazing.
I agree; you should watch Thief again. I hadn’t seen it in years and I enjoyed it more this time around.
Thanks for reading, Stacey.
–Pam
LikeLiked by 1 person