It would be hard to commit yourself to the practice of medicine, especially as a surgeon–a general surgeon to be exact. You would have to dedicate–I don’t know–at least fifteen years to schooling. And that’s just the tip of the ice burg.
All the stress. The browbeating from superiors. The tightwire dance between life and death. The dodging bullets of malpractice because everyone, no matter how brilliant, makes mistakes. The “we did everything we could” talks with the family. The sleep depravation. And so on.
And so forth.
But the “honor” of handling someone’s intestines, of piecing a liver back together, of stemming a hemorrhaging spleen, yes, of saving life and limb makes it worth it. And if not that, then the money and the prestige should do the trick…except when they don’t. That’s the predicament character Dr. Alex Brantley finds himself in within the roughly three hundred pages of Arthur Herbert’s–himself a general surgeon–medical thriller, The Cuts That Cure.

Better suited as a general practitioner than a general surgeon, Dr. Brantley is burned out and in deep medical school debt. Then, to add serious bodily harm–torture, really–to insult, a badly burned baby turns up in the E.R. and it’s evident that the child has been purposely scalded. It’s the final straw. Dr. Brantley quits, but not before he disfigures the white trash baby mama/daddy car with a tire iron.
And he’s just getting started.
Alex–don’t call him Dr. Brantley anymore–checks into a no-tell-motel and attempts suicide, only to wake up disappointed in a psych-ward. He does his mandatory time in said psych-ward before making his way to a small town in the scrubby draw of the Texas hill country. There he settles in an efficiency apartment above the garage of a kindly old land lady, but not before he rescues a dog–24 hours away from euthanasia, of course.
He hires an attractive lady lawyer to help him wiggle out of some of his medical school debt and pays the rent as a high school science teacher where one of his students happens to be a burgeoning serial killer. The kid’s name is Henry.
Okay. Now we’re cookin’ with Crisco.
Only we’re not.
That’s cause author Herbert keeps takin’ the damn skillet off the damn burner. He kills Henry off with about another one hundred fifty pages to go.
Sure, there’s sub plots and parallel narratives, stuff like that going on. That’s the problem. The plot thickens to the point of embolism.
Let’s see, Alex takes up with a dubious real estate lawyer–not sexually, everybody’s respectfully heterosexual here; besides that, the lawyer has a paunch–who introduces him to a notoriously evil cartel lieutenant and the elegant but even more evil jefe of the cartel. (Yeah, you guessed it, the cartel boss is long winded. He likes to tell stories.) And, well, you know…every cartel needs a doctor on the payroll.
So you can pretty much guess where this is going, some whiplash inducing twists and turns notwithstanding. Hey, it is a thriller–and a medical one at that.
Herbert does a respectable job, especially considering that this is his first published novel; he is a surgeon after all. Nonetheless, though his hands are deft with a scalpel, no doubt, perhaps he should dial it back on all the plot juggling until he has a bit more experience. Just because you can pull off a laparotomy and a face lift at the same time doesn’t mean that you should.
Great post 🙂 I will be interested in seeing where Arthur Herbert will go from here 🙂 Anyway, keep up the great work as always 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, John. It will be interesting to see where his next novel leads. He has potential.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review, Pam. Seems like he threw six ideas into one book, and couldn’t decide which one to stick with.
Best wishes, Pete.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, thanks, Pete. Yep, that’s exactly my take on it. If he’d of just stuck with Henry the burgeoning serial killer…oh, well. Thanks for reading.
–Pam
LikeLiked by 1 person
It sounds like there is too much going on…way too much but the main part of the story sounds good.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep. That’s it. Thanks for reading Max. Happy Thanksgiving!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Happy Thanksgiving to you Pam!
LikeLiked by 1 person
That sounds like a fun one, Pam. I’m always interested when doctors turn to writing. Not that they CAN’T write, but one would imagine they’re very left brained, you know? I think the left brain/right brain stuff has been partially pooh-poohed, actually, by now.
But Michael Crighton was really good (he had a degree but didn’t practice) and I read a couple of comedies a young woman who had recently become a doctor wrote (about becoming a doctor) and they were hilarious. It is really truly scary the stress they’re under when training and the lack of sleep they get. It makes absolutely no sense that the medical profession operates that way.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey Stacey. Happy Thanksgiving! I’ve been wandering about you. I’ve emailed you twice about the guest post I’m supposed to do for you…that I WANT to do for you, but crickets…maybe it went into your spam folder…or you didn’t get it…or you changed your mind about the post…anyway, I’m cool with banging it out in the next couple of days or not….just glad to hear from you. About the doctor…yeah, my thoughts are…aren’t thrillers a little low brow for an MD. I mean you guys do the goose liver pate and leave the corn dogs to Karin Slaughter and the like. I love corndogs by the way.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh boy, ha ha , same here, Pam! I saw your emails and responded at least twice! And then…crickets. I knew you were having problems with your email but wasn’t sure if it was that or you were busy. So I decided not to push it. We need a better way to communicate, lol. I’d be great if you still wanna write something up soon! But what is going ON with the email? I’ll send you a note tonight and see if you get it.
Meanwhile, thrillers DO seem a tad bit low brow for MDs, right? Especially just out and out murder. Judge, jury, and executioner, eh? Doogie Howser meets Dexter meets Death Wish.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Absolutely. But back to your point about doctors and sleep deprivation…it’s sadistic what they go through…and some of their superiors are sadists. So I got on this thread once that was all MDs and DOs…Oh my gosh! The surgeons where so awful…so condescending to everyone else. They ganged up on this gynecologist…said gynecologist shouldn’t be allowed to do surgery…that they wouldn’t let a gynecologist spay their dog…it was so demeaning…and, yet, it gave me pause…what if I ever needed gynecological surgery? Ha! Anyway, the experience of visiting that site was almost as uncomfortable as going to the doctor. Ha!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wow. Going on that site would have made my blood boil. So weird! What’s the actual point of having an ego so big all you’re doing is causing emotional damage everywhere you go? You know, “Do no harm” extends to people’s psyches too. But…oh, well! All that schooling, all the gray matter it takes to become a doctor, especially a surgeon, combined with actually extending the life of those who would be dead otherwise….their egos must expand like an unstoppable black hole, lol.
And the comedian/doctor that I was reading talked about the abuse too. How the interns are thrust into this chaotic life and death world, and questions are met with impatience and scorn, and any error, even small ones (how can you NOT make mistakes?) are basically unforgivable. And all of this with no sleep. I can barely remember my name when I don’t get enough sleep. How is someone supposed to diagnose an illness properly with no sleep? Incredible. If I survived all that and thrived afterward, I don’t know, I might become an egomaniac too. I don’t know, lol !!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nice review Pam, I enjoyed this book and reviewed it as well. I thought is was good for a debut book and feel Herbert has a lot more to offer with a bit of restraint and a deft hand.
LikeLike
Yeah, you liked this one more than I did–I bought the book because of your review…Ha! But, yeah, he can write. And it’s a solid debut.
Thanks.
–Pam
LikeLike